Customer Reviews for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
This product is no longer available. Continue shopping at JCPenney.
Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
Stafford® Performance Super shirt is our best-selling style and looks the definition of professional when paired with a sharp tie.
Shirt features:
wrinkle-free performance
comfort-stretch point collar; patch pocket
stain-repel Scotchgard™ technology
Tie features:
luxurious silk
fully lined
Average Customer Rating:
(94 Reviews) 65
Rating Breakdown 94 reviews
5 stars
74
4 stars
12
3 stars
0
2 stars
3
1 star
5
87 of 94(93%)reviewers would recommend this product.
Customer Reviews for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
Review 1 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Best Biz casual shirt
PostedFebruary 7, 2011
Written By: mpinkosky
from Minneapolis, MN
Age: 50-60
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Frequently
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"easy care, always looks sharp when I travel to customer site or in town at the office"
Pros easy care
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 2 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
good dress shirt
PostedJanuary 24, 2011
Written By: hasseledmom
from San Antonio, Texas
Age: 40-49
Gender: Female
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Frequently
Value
4
out of
5
Fit
4
out of
5
Styling
4
out of
5
"My son just went from boys sizes to mens sizes, but still a lilttle small and this shirt comes in a 14 neck. his dad wears this style in an 18 neck and they both fit well and wear real well. They last. so a good value"
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 3 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Son's favorite shirts
PostedJanuary 24, 2011
Written By: Fenwickwv
from WV
Age: 50-60
Gender: Female
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Frequently
Value
4
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
4
out of
5
"I buy these shirts for my sons, they are their favorite shirts to wear for dress and work, the tall fits my xxxlg son in the sleeves and lengh he loves these shirts. Only con is that they wear thin in the elbows after a time. But they wash up very nice, few wrinkles!"
Pros Fits and is comfortable
Cons ebows wear thin
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 4 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Excellent shirt with great pricing
PostedJanuary 15, 2011
Written By: Anonymous
from Flowood, MS
Age: 50-60
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Frequently
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"The Stafford® Performance Broadcloth shirts are fantastic. These are the best shirts I have found. With JCPenney's sales and discounts, you can usually get a great price. I load up on thewhite ones often, but they do have other colors that really look good. i highjly reccomend these shirts."
Pros Stretch collar, fit, high quality
Cons none
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 5 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Just an all around awesome shirt
PostedJanuary 10, 2011
Written By: JCPoppa
Age: 30-39
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Occasionally
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"This shirt is great. I just wish some of the other colors (I got yellow) were available more often. Seems to be a popular shirt and it is sold out frequently."
Pros Wrinkle resistant, excellent fit, quality, comfort
Cons Out of stock frequently :(
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 6 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Great Shirt
PostedDecember 31, 2010
Written By: Anonymous
from Texas
Age: Over 60
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Frequently
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
4
out of
5
"If you have to wear a dress shirt for work everyday, i have found these shirts to be the best and at the best value of any brand that I have ever tried over the last 40 years of wearing dress shirts. The "super" shirt is a great idea and I hope they stay in production."
Pros Wears and looks great.
Cons Material a little thin
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 7 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Excellent Shirt
PostedDecember 30, 2010
Written By: atobi001
Age: 25-29
Gender: Female
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Occasionally
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"My husband is 6'8", so we have trouble finding shirts that fit properly. These shirts fit him wonderfully. It is sad that they are only available online but you would think he bought them in a store, that is how well they fit. The only downside is that there aren't that many colors available"
Pros Great tailoring
Cons I wish they had more colors
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 8 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
PostedDecember 30, 2010
Written By: Titu
from Okeechobee, FL
Age: 50-60
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Occasionally
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"This a good product for the price. The size is true to fit."
Pros great value
Cons none
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 9 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
great value and quality
PostedDecember 29, 2010
Written By: olddude
Age: 40-49
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Occasionally
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
4
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"Athletic fit still has to be tapered but the price and quality is better than custom made shirts"
Pros Much better than the thinner material dress shirts, unless it is hte heat of summer.
Cons HAve not had them long enough to knwo how well they hold up or shrink
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 10 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Poor Quality
PostedDecember 28, 2010
Written By: shalG
from California
Age: 40-49
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Occasionally
Value
3
out of
5
Fit
3
out of
5
Styling
1
out of
5
"Poor Quality Fabric Material. Returned to Store."
Pros none
Cons Poor Quality Material
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 11 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Great shirt
PostedDecember 28, 2010
Written By: pkonecny
Age: 50-60
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Occasionally
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
4
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"I take a full 35" length, not available. 34/35 is too short, and 36/37 is too long. These shirts are the only ones I will every buy. Great colors, but need more. Athletic fit shirts best for large neck size, 17 ½ with ave. waste size 36/37 person."
Pros best value, price, color, fit, look, fabric, ware
Cons does not come in full length, I take a full 35" not available
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 12 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Stafford Big & Tall
PostedDecember 28, 2010
Written By: golfhousestud
Age: 40-49
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Frequently
Value
4
out of
5
Fit
1
out of
5
Styling
4
out of
5
"With the need to buy a larger shirt to allow for my neck size the body of the shirt is extremely too large.
The shoulder was cut down to the middle of my bicep. I will be returning this shirt."
Pros Nice Looking Shirt
Cons Fit is awful.
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 13 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Overall great shirt
PostedDecember 13, 2010
Written By: coltsfan
Age: 50-60
Gender: Female
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Frequently
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"Purchased a total of three Stafford shirts based on the reviews of others. My husband is very happy with the fit and comfort. I am very happy that they look great right out of the dryer."
Pros Love the no wrinkle. Fit good.
Cons none
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 14 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Stafford Shirts - Excellent Value
PostedDecember 13, 2010
Written By: rogocop
Age: 50-60
Gender: Female
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Occasionally
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"Stafford Shirts are the only permanent press shirts I purchase for my husband and two sons. In this busy world, we don't have time to iron. Stafford shirts are of high quality, are a great value and always provide a good fit. I highly recommend any shirt in the Stafford line."
Pros No Iron Needed - Great Fit - Fashionable
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 15 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Excellent shirt
PostedDecember 13, 2010
Written By: BigBossMan
Age: Over 60
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Frequently
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"Stafford performance shirts are the best I've found for my purposes. They look good, consistently fit well, and have a couple of features I particularly like--the extra length of the tail with its rotated buttonhole and the elastic collar button. I recommend these shirts to any person who wears dress shirts and ties, especially daily to work."
Pros appearance, fit, durability
Cons none
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 16 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
What a shirt!
PostedNovember 30, 2010
Written By: Berkleymom
from suburban Detroit
Age: Over 60
Gender: Female
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Occasionally
Value
4
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"The shirt fits well and the material is great. It is wrinkle resistant. My husband especially like the fact that the neck button is on an elastic strip."
Pros It fit my husband well and he liked it
Cons none
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 17 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Supershirt
PostedNovember 30, 2010
Written By: CMackDaddio
Age: 50-60
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Frequently
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"I have been buying the Stafford White Shirts with the elastic neck button for years. Great dress shirt."
Pros Quality, Fit, Value
Cons None
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 18 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Big disappointment as substitute for all-cotton
PostedNovember 16, 2010
Written By: prontotype
from New York, NY
Age: 40-49
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Occasionally
Value
1
out of
5
Fit
3
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"I was very disappointed to learn that the Performance Traveler shirts (which are not THESE shirts) had been discontinued. Given my complete satisfaction with them previously, I decided to try the Stafford Performance Super shirt as a substitute despite the fact that they are only 55% cotton.
After wearing one of the two shirts I ordered I returned both of them. They are a complete disappointment and I would not recommend them to anyone at any price.
• They look and feel cheap. The fabric is unpleasant to the touch and too thin and see-through to wear for business purposes, with or without a t-shirt.
• The fit is terrible. I ordered the same 32/33" sleeve as the Performance Travelers but these are clearly too short for my arm length and are barely large enough in diameter to accommodate a wristwatch.
• The monogram is placed too close to the inside of the sleeve. The letters are also poorly formed.
I considered ordering the Stafford Signature Executive shirt which is all cotton but the reviews here complained consistently about the thinness of the fabric and I am not interested in repeating this experiment. The Claiborne shirt is not monogrammable and I was confused by the styles offered as neither "slim/modern" nor "big" sounds like it particularly applies to me. Van Heusen is another cotton/poly blend. None of the other shirts on your website meet my basic requirements.
In discontinuing the core quality Stafford shirt, you have most likely lost me as a JC Penney store customer. My expectations for quality in a staple shirt have been disappointed and I am not likely to take the time to go into the store again.
I will most definitely not be ordering any other shirts from JC Penney's website until you once again offer a shirt of comparable quality to the 100% cotton Stafford Performance Traveler that Consumer Reports also found to be so excellent. And for the record I would of course be willing to pay more than last year's price for a comparable shirt."
After wearing one of the two shirts I ordered I returned both of them. They are a complete disappointment and I would not recommend them to anyone at any price.
• They look and feel cheap. The fabric is unpleasant to the touch and too thin and see-through to wear for business purposes, with or without a t-shirt.
• The fit is terrible. I ordered the same 32/33" sleeve as the Performance Travelers but these are clearly too short for my arm length and are barely large enough in diameter to accommodate a wristwatch.
• The monogram is placed too close to the inside of the sleeve. The letters are also poorly formed.
I considered ordering the Stafford Signature Executive shirt which is all cotton but the reviews here complained consistently about the thinness of the fabric and I am not interested in repeating this experiment. The Claiborne shirt is not monogrammable and I was confused by the styles offered as neither "slim/modern" nor "big" sounds like it particularly applies to me. Van Heusen is another cotton/poly blend. None of the other shirts on your website meet my basic requirements.
In discontinuing the core quality Stafford shirt, you have most likely lost me as a JC Penney store customer. My expectations for quality in a staple shirt have been disappointed and I am not likely to take the time to go into the store again.
I will most definitely not be ordering any other shirts from JC Penney's website until you once again offer a shirt of comparable quality to the 100% cotton Stafford Performance Traveler that Consumer Reports also found to be so excellent. And for the record I would of course be willing to pay more than last year's price for a comparable shirt."
Pros Good styling
Cons Horrible cheap thin fabric; poorly-applied monogram
Share:
+1point
1of 1voted this as helpful.
Review 19 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Love, love these shirts
PostedNovember 16, 2010
Written By: cd3658
from Utah
Age: Over 60
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Frequently
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
5
out of
5
"This is the best shirt I have ever found and won't buy any other now. It always looks fresh and stylish."
Pros Expandable neck, wrinkle free, collar looks great
Cons none
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 20 for Stafford® Performance Broadcloth
overall rating
Great Shirt for tall guy
PostedNovember 16, 2010
Written By: LoveMyLakeEffect
Age: 25-29
Gender: Male
How often do you shop at JCPenney? Frequently
Value
5
out of
5
Fit
5
out of
5
Styling
4
out of
5
"Tall, thin guys don't have much choice when it comes to finding good shirts with a 16" neck and a 36/37 sleeve (unless you feel like paying an arm and a leg for a custom-made shirt), so these shirts work great! They look great on TV, and are the only shirts I own for work. Only downside I can think of is that I have to watch carefully for when they are in stock, then pounce-they are frequently out of stock."
Pros Great fit, easy to wash
Cons Frequently out of stock
Share:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.